With Such Words
if you aren't a hypocrite, your moral standards aren't high enough
Mansfield Park: Chapter 1 
4th-Jun-2013 06:56 pm
talibusorabat: A silouette of a girl sitting crosslegged and reading "Sirens" (pic#1116653)
So I said I'd be back in July with Legend of Korra, but a friend of mine and I are doing a re-read of Jane Austen's Mansfield Park so yay! I return early.

Mansfield Park and I have a funny history. I first read it when I was fairly young, and I loved it. I was shy, retiring and extremely prissy, and Fanny Price spoke to me.

I grew up, became slightly less shy and infinitely less prissy, and when I read it again in late high school/early college, I found myself still liking Fanny, but much more uncomfortable with my perception of her very rigid, stern morality.

Over half a decade of continued growing later, I'm curious to see how I'll react now.


Ahahaha poor Sir Thomas. I love the way Austen sets up her characters. I'm not sure a modern writer could get away with the telling rather than showing, but I find her narrative voice so charming that I'd let her tell me everything.

I also like the contrast in the three marriages: Lord and Lady Bertram, Mr. & Mrs. Norris, and Mr. & Mrs. Price. None of them genuine love matches, but all in different ways.

Lady Bertram's is a shallow relationship (reminiscent of Mr. and Mrs. Bennet's, actually) -- from the very first sentence, it's clear that whatever feeling there was in the relationship was on Sir Thomas' side.

Miss Maria Ward...had the good luck to captivate Sir Thomas Bertram

Lady Bertram isn't an object; she is the subject of the sentence, but she is passive. She didn't set out to captivate him; she just got lucky.

Mrs. Norris married simply for money, and Mrs. Price married impulsively, as an act of rebellion more than passion.

Class, of course, is an issue from the get-go.

Also, I forgot how short her chapters are. Aiya! Looking forward to meeting Fanny.
Comments 
5th-Jun-2013 12:01 am (UTC)
tigerlily: Tara smiling (Tara smiling)
And all the matches are described so practically too - passions like greed, pride, and rebelliousness, sounding impressive in the abstract, are shrunk small to fit the people they come from. None of the characters' feelings rise over the rest.

I think that's why I like the telling. It seems to describe the characters in a nonjudgmental way, making the judgment more credible.
5th-Jun-2013 01:32 am (UTC)
talibusorabat: Reckon I'll leave my brans at home, then (North & South: Brains at Home)
Exactly! That's one of the things I love about Austen overall -- she has such great affection for all of her characters, no matter how "awful" they are. I feel like a lot of the film adaptations miss this.
5th-Jun-2013 03:10 am (UTC)
tigerlily: Cornelia not taking it (Cornelia not taking it)
I haven't watched many of the films, but the one I remember most has me inclined to agree. It was the 1999 Mansfield Park, and it had this dramatic sequence of finding Henry in bed with Maria and I was just this icon.
5th-Jun-2013 03:58 am (UTC) - I made a different comment instead of an edit so I could use this icon.
tigerlily: Taranee boss (Taranee boss)
And! Instead of Edmund eventually seeing qualities that were already there in Mary, she openly tells the whole family that it's okay if Tom dies, because Edmund will then be the heir!
7th-Jun-2013 01:58 am (UTC)
talibusorabat: A black woman in hijab looks unimmpressed (LMP: Fatima Excuse me?)
AHAHAHA OH LORD. I think I remember that one. Yeah, that's an unnecessary upping the sex factor, too.
This page was loaded Jul 4th 2025, 7:25 pm GMT.